Morality, Law & Ethics

Does the following hypothetical scenario illustrate immoral or illegal behavior?
You see someone drowning and calling desperately for help. You simply look on and make no effort to help.
Immoral?Illegal?
Does the following hypothetical scenario illustrate immoral or illegal behavior?
Country X has imposed a night curfew on teenagers to try to curb teen violence. You, a teenager, venture out after curfew hours.
Immoral?Illegal?
Does the following hypothetical scenario illustrate immoral or illegal behavior?
In February 1997 the Roslin Institute in Scotland reported that it had cloned a sheep, Dolly. Is cloning a human:
Immoral?Illegal?
Is being ethical the same as:
  • Following our feelings?
  • Being religious?
  • Following the law?
  • Doing whatever our society accepts?
Four Ethical Philosophies
  • Pragmatism: Reality is a process. Nothing is always good or always bad. The end justifies the means. Value is measured by what is of practical benefit to society.
  • Existentialism: Reality is defined by each individual who chooses his/her own truth. Value is measured by what an individual responsibly chooses as good.
  • Idealism: Reality is based on ideas. Ethical action is based on duty, moral imperatives and absolutes. You must never lie. Value is measured by conformity to ideas.
  • Realism: Reality exists in the material object, not in the immaterial mind. Ethical actions follows what is natural. Value is measured by conformity to nature.
Can Ethics Be Taught?
Research in field of moral development (Kohlberg)
  • Young adults experience dramatic changes in their 20's and 30's in problem-solving strategies used to deal with ethical issues.
  • These changes are linked to changes in how a person perceives society & his/her role in society.
  • Amount of change is related to number of years in formal education at college.
  • Formal education to influence awareness of moral problems & to influence reasoning process is effective.
  • Person's behavior is influenced by his/her moral perception and moral judgements.
Kohlberg's 6 Stages of Moral Development (based on men only)
LevelStageSocial Orientation
Pre-conventional1Obedience & punishment - child
 2One's own best interest
Conventional3"Good boy/girl" - group loyalties
 4Law & order, duty
Post-conventional5Social-contract legalistic - welfare of others
 5Principled conscience